Action Research (Inquiry) Project

If two schools in different use essentially the same Standards of Learning how will the outcome of the same assignment compare? Upon arrival at Marymount International School I discovered that the standards used for elementary school art were adapted from the Virginia standards of learning, in some cases the standard was the exact same wording.  I chose to take a deeper look at this idea because I was interested in finding out what role culture and upbringing play in the production of artwork among kids the same age and given the same assignment.  During an elementary practicum experience in Elkton, Virginia I taught students in first grade a lesson about showing texture in artwork, using the book Where the Wild Things Are to inspire the students. The lesson overview and standards of learning were as follows:

Lesson Overview
The world around us is filled with different lines, patterns, and textures, but how do we know just by looking at something if it will be soft or hard, smooth or rough? In this lesson students will discuss how lines and patterns create texture both on the wild things in Maurice Sendak’s book Where the Wild Things Are and in their immediate environment.  Students will create their own wild thing using crayons and/or markers – taking line and pattern into consideration to create the illusion of texture in their artwork.

Standards of Learning
1.1  The student will recognize and discuss various solutions to a single art problem.
1.3 The student will identify and use (2) line and line variations – zigzag, dotted, wavy, and spiral; (3) texture – visual and tactile; (5) patterns – alternating and repeating.
1.4 The student will create works of art inspired by spoken and written stories and poems.
1.5 The student will create art from real and imaginary sources of inspiration.

*The Virginia standards of learning I had previously chosen were nearly identical to the standards used at Marymount International School. Differences were so small they were not worth noting.

Visual Culture
During the class discussion of the use of lines to create texture in Where the Wild Things Are various things in the room will be pointed out to students and they will discuss how they might draw them using line and pattern.  For example, a tabletop might be drawn with a dark, straight marker line and a child’s curly hair might be hard with swirl strokes of a crayon at varying pressure.
*While the students’ visual culture is very different, their immediate visual culture in the classroom had many similarities so the same visual culture discussion was used for both groups.

In order to study this issue more closely, I first took time to reflect on my experience teaching first grade students this lesson in Elkton, Virginia.  I talked to my cooperating teacher at Marymount International School to see if she thought the lesson was acceptable to teach and she agreed it was both age and content appropriate.  After teaching the lesson I reflected on how the students enjoyed the lesson as well as things that worked and didn’t work, at first I did not take the Elkton students into consideration. I wanted to take an unbiased look at the Marymount International School students. After taking time to reflect upon each teaching experience individually I began to compare and contrast each group of students. I compared and contrasted the following areas and my conclusions are listed below.

-Understanding of the lesson and expectations: Both groups of students generally understood the lesson. The concept of using line to show texture was a bit abstract for each group of students, but I think the lesson served as way to get students thinking about how to draw texture even if they didn’t exactly realize that is what they were doing.

-Enjoyment of assignment: Students in Elkton, Virginia were extremely excited from me to read Where the Wild Things Are to the class even though the majority of the students had seen and read the book previously. At Marymount the students all appeared excited to see the book and to tell me that they had heard it before, but a lot less excited to actually hear the story.

-Knowledge of texture: Both student groups understood the questions about texture that I asked as well as how to use lines, but Marymount students had more trouble taking what they said and learned in class discussions and putting it down on paper.

-Knowledge of art materials: Both students were given the option to use crayons, markers, or both for their assignment. Students at Marymount strongly preferred to use markers and expressed a dislike for using crayons. Elkton, Virginia students also preferred to use markers but didn’t show a strong preference for one over the other. Elkton students had access to markers during each class when they finished an assignment early and could free draw, but Marymount students were limited to using crayons for most drawing assignments. I believe that both student groups had the same knowledge of the materials, but Marymount students did not appreciate crayons as much because they felt forced to use them for assignments and markers seemed more special to use.

-Outcome: Both Marymount and Elkton students created fun, cute, and scary wild things inspired by Where the Wild Things Are, Elkton students better utilized line to create textures, those students were also able to finish their assignment faster. Marymount students did not all fully complete the assignment in the same amount of time.

I believe my findings from this idea and observation will be important in my future teaching because I hope to teach in the DC area or abroad, both would offer a diverse student population. It will be important for me to realize that even though students may be learning the same thing and possess the same skill set the outcome of their assignments will be different because of their culture and upbringing. This will be a crucial idea to keep with me through out my teaching because it will remind me of the importance of differentiating for students, especially when culture and language are involved. Each student will express him or herself differently and have a different idea of what the assignment outcome should look like. I think it is more important that students try their hardest and are able to discuss and justify their art making decisions, even if their artwork is different from the rest of the class.  I would like to continue to document the differences and similarities in student work in regards to the students’ culture and upbringing.





No comments:

Post a Comment